L.L.Bean

Although L.L.Bean's Christmas collection is limited, you might still be able to find exactly what you're looking for, especially if you're seeking a classic feel. While L.L.Bean doesn't have the same variety of Christmas gifts as some of the other retailers on the list, it does have a few items that fit the rustic theme. Unfussy yet festive birchbark centerpieces, plaid tree skirts, and flannel bedding (They're also our top picks in our best flannel sheets guide.)

There are also a variety of needlepoint stockings to hang from the fireplace at the business. These can also be personalized, so no one will know you didn't use your needle and thread.

Good for: Flannel sheets, stockings