Piccadilly Attic

Piccadilly Attic, the fifth most expensive Beanie Baby on the list, is worth a whooping $120,000, making him the first to break the $100,000 barrier.

Piccadilly Attic was released in 1998, coming from the Attic Treasure family. It is a no-brainer for any collector if you can get beyond his creepiness and focus on his other attributes. Clowns aren't the most popular item among children, so Ty's decision to make him back in the day may not have been the best.

Although not all types of Piccadilly Attic are valuable, some, such as Piccadilly with unusual coloring, are extremely rare and therefore pricey. Piccadilly was likewise not the most popular Beanie Baby, thus he was only made for a short time. As a result, fewer variations exist than other Beanie Babies, making them even more unusual.

It's even better if you have a Piccadilly Attic with an intact incorrect tag. Mint-condition items will also get a higher price from collectors. Some lucky owners, on the other hand, will be delighted they did because his value has skyrocketed in recent years!

Price: $125,000